Calling all pizza lovers: Trattoria Mercatto, Toronto Eaton Centre’s resident Italian eatery and wine bar, is THE place to be! I know we all have our favourite pizza takeout place. The one we fall back on when we want to cozy up on the couch with the remote in front of the tv munching on pizza in our jammies or sweats. But let me tell you, when you feel like dining out for the wood-fired oven goodness with some wine, a few good appetizers, and a sweet dessert to end the meal, you want the super good stuff and I am over the moon that I can say that Trattoria Mercatto has the stuff pizza dreams are made of.
You might be thinking, “wow, that’s quite the proclamation!” After all, there are many places in the city that serve pizza. I haven’t tried them all (and I don’t think I ever will!), but I have tried my fair share and I can tell when I’ve come across something average, something good, and something fan-freakin’-tastic. I mean serious business. When I eat food that is tripping over the line of amazing, it deserves several good hooplas and cartwheels and in this case, a very happy blog post!
This even takes me by surprise. I’ve always been wary of restaurants in malls. When I was in high school and university, my friends and I would go to them more so out of convenience than anything else. And while I’ve never had anything awful, I’ve also never had anything memorable. Mall restaurants conjure up feelings of bland, ho-hum, and ordinary. There’s no excitement, no real creativity in it for me. But I wanted to give Trattoria Mercatto a chance. For starters, it’s located inside my favourite mall. Second, it’s pretty, fresh, and airy on the inside with a nice outdoor patio overlooking the park by Dundas and Bay. Third, my best friend had gone before me and reported back saying she enjoyed it so I knew it had to be good because I trust her judgment and between the two of us, she’s definitely more critical. And finally, it’s Italian and I never say no to Italian. Trattoria Mercatto hasn’t been a long-time fixture in the Eaton Centre, but it’s been there long enough to impress, so I knew it was only a matter of time before I caved and went. And oh my god was this first visit one of the most terrific lunches ever.
Their regular daily menu is comprised of antipasti and salads (ricotta and Italian speck crostini, Sicilian fried cauliflower, beet and arugula salad with Italian burrata cheese), Italian panini sandwiches, (mortadella, prosciutto, artichoke pesto, fior di latte cheese), Italian cheese boards, lots of Italian pasta dishes (orecchiette, bucatini, ravioli, pappardelle, and more with sausages, cheeses, and vegetables), meat and fish, and the star of the show for me, pizzas! Prices are around $14-$20 for entrees and pizzas, and $7-$11 for appetizers and salads.
I do love the regular menu but what I really love the most is how they have special weekly menu features and seasonal spotlights on different ingredients! Each and every single week, Mercatto will make a post on their website indicating that week’s features and special menus and/or menu items. Their site keeps everyone up-to-date on seasonal produce and ingredients, new dishes, and news and announcements. I absolutely love checking up on their site once a week, just to see what types of dishes they’ve used special seasonal ingredients for and the approach they’re taking to menu creation. There’s often a special entree and appetizer and sometimes a dessert and there’s always a seasonal focus. For example, one of their weekly specials shined a spotlight on their buffalo meat, used in a pasta bolognese with bufala cheese milked from the same local farm animals.
Trattoria Mercatto at the Eaton Cente is also lovely to dine in. There are bar tables closer to the front entrance and more intimate tables further in, surrounded by barrels and displays of wine and bottles and giant windows overlooking the park and patio. It’s a serene setting that’s perfect for a weekend lunch out, fun group gathering, or a romantic dinner on the town. I love it. And I love their pizza.
Their pizza menu features 10 different kinds with lots of differents meats, cheese, and vegetables adorning each one: artichokes, black olives, spicy soppressata (Italian dry salami), cured Italian ham, basil, rapini, eggplant, goat cheese, mushrooms, pancetta, fennel sausage, and so much more. I was debating between one of their paninis and the zucchini pizza ($15.50) and my craving for “dining out” pizza won over so zucchini it was! The pizzas are the perfect size for a great-size meal for a single person (I am not ashamed to say that I polished my pizza off feeling awsome while my best friend, who can pack it in even better than I can, was full to bursting after hers!) and if I had to describe the size, I’d say the circumference is comparable to that of a floppy brimmed hat.
My zucchini pizza was bejeweled with grilled zucchini slices, caramelized red onion, smoked ricotta di bufala, tomato, and a huuuuge helping of fresh arugula. I thought I had died and gone to pizza heaven. OH.MY.GOD. This pizza was so unbelivably scrumptious, delicious, and foodgasmic. I kept murmuring, “this is so good!” between bites. I couldn’t believe how amazing it was. This is “I just want to inhale the whole thing because it’s so delicious” good. Or “I don’t ever want to finish this pizza because I wan’t to savour every bite” good. It wasn’t laden with grease and the ingredients weren’t sparsely sprinkled. It was covered inch to inch and bursting with colour and flavour. The cheese was warm and creamy, the onions and zucchini were so sweet in flavour, and the arugula? I wish I had a whole extra bowl of it to sprinkle on.
What really pushed this pizza over the top for me though was the crust. Let it be known that while I love pizza, I don’t give two cents about the crust. Most of the time, I couldn’t care less about it. I consider it as something that is just part of the pizza and, well, there. It’s never captured my heart because often times it’s too chewy, too tough, too dry, too bland. Their crust? I inhaled it. I didn’t even have second thoughts. No, “hmm, maybe I’ll just leave this part on the side of my plate” or, “hmm, it’s a little tough, meh”. I munched on every morsel of pizza, crust and body, like it was my last time eating awesome pizza. The crust was so crispy, so airy and so darn good. None of those negative aspects I mentioned above even entered this realm. THAT is the true testament of a fab pizza: delicious from top to bottom. And judging how much this experience made and makes me gush, I wouldn’t be surprised if their whole menu was wonderful from top to bottom as well.
Trattoria Mercatto is located at 220 Yonge Street inside The Eaton Centre on the 3rd floor on the northern, Dundas Street end of the shopping centre. They serve 3 other locations in Toronto under the Mercatto name (Bay & Adelaide, Toronto Street, and the Mars Discovery District on College Street). They are open for both lunch and dinner 7 days a week (Monday-Saturday 11:30am-11pm, Sunday 12pm-9pm at the Eaton Centre location). Click HERE to view their website with menus, upcoming events, catering, news, and more! Stay tuned for tomorrow’s dessert post!